Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Who is to Blame for Terrorism? (Tawfik Hamid)

An excellent article from a Muslim scholar. See his bio data at the end of this article. His fifth point highlighted in red and bold letters is my personal emphasis.

Who is to Blame for Terrorism?
by Tawfik Hamid 

The recent terrorist attempt in New York's Times Square [1] (possibly conducted by Islamist terrorists) [2] and the global nature of Islamic terrorism [3] in the last few decades raises an important question: Who is to blame for these acts of terror?
Let us assume that a father teaches a child to hate his neighbor. Years pass and the child becomes a young adult full of hatred towards this neighbor leading to the end scenario where the young man kills his neighbor. Shall we only blame the child for killing the neighbor or shall we also blame the person (or people) who taught him how to hate?  Is it acceptable to ignore the role of the teaching person in this process of killing? The same applies to terrorism, Shall we only blame the terrorists who conduct the attacks or also blame those who taught them how to hate 'others'?
It is easy to only blame the terrorists for the attack; however, deep analysis of the problem reveals a better understanding and allows for better answers to such questions. Looking back on the Nazi regime and its barbaric inhumane atrocities against the Jews illustrates the dynamics of evil.  This type of cruelty has set an example to understand Islamism terrorism and who is to blame.
The following people should be held responsible for contributing to the atrocities of Nazi's:
1-     Adolf Hitler and those who taught the ideology of hate.
2-    The system that allowed such an ideology to flourish such as the Nazi party.
3-    The soldiers who conducted the killing of the innocents.
4-    Those who stayed silent until millions of people were killed.
5-    Those who encouraged the Holocaust by verbal or logistical support.

Similarly, in the case of Islamist terrorism the following must be held accountable:
1-      Those who promote religiously based ideology of hatred toward Non Muslims. It is easy to detect a level of hatred in many mainstream Islamic books and media sources [4].
 2-      The Islamic systems that adopted, encouraged, and supported such negative forms of teaching in the last few decades.  These include many radical mosques and Islamic schools. The role of the Wahhabi regimen of Saudi Arabia in promoting such an ideology should not be ignored [5].
 3-    The terrorists who accepted such teachings of hatred and materialized it into violence.
4-    The passive attitude of many in the Muslim world against the terrorists [6].
5-     Those who abused the values of Liberty and allowed the ideology of hate to grow under the banner of religious freedom.
 All of the above are to blame and should be held responsible for the problem of Islamic terrorism as each has contributed to the growth of this phenomenon. Individual terrorists play the role of the soldiers who killed the Jews during the Nazi era. It is not enough to only blame the soldiers without blaming the leaders of the system and those who promoted the ideology of hatred.  Similarly it is unreasonable not to hold accountable those scholars and Islamic systems that preach, teach, or promote hatred toward Non Muslims. Stopping the hatred is the first step toward ending terrorism.

6 See:  Inside Jihad -Understanding and Confronting Radical Islam by Tawfik Hmaid (Pages: 91-96)
Dr. Tawfik Hamid
Dr. Tawfik Hamid
Dr. Tawfik Hamid (aka Tarek Abdelhamid), is an Islamic thinker and reformer, and one time Islamic extremist from Egypt. He was a member of a terrorist Islamic organization JI with Dr. Ayman Al-Zawaherri who became later on the second in command of Al-Qaeda. Dr. Hamid is currently a Senior Fellow and Chair of the study of Islamic Radicalism at the Potomac Institute for Policy Studies.

No comments:

Post a Comment